Having watched virtually every minute of every game, these are my grades and observations.
Gordon Hayward: A
Prior to sustaining a freak broken bone in his hand in an unnecessary collision delivered by Lamarcus Aldridge, Hayward was excellent in every aspect of the game on both ends of the floor. Let’s hope he returns on schedule because he provides important balance and experience to the team. While he was playing, the offense was far more fluid than it has been since his absence.
Jayson Tatum: B+
All the so-called pundits continue to lavish high praise on Tatum because he obviously possesses an excellent skill set. And he has had several moments where he has made plays which attract great attention. However, he also remains somewhat inconsistent on both ends of the floor and has yet to find a balance between dominating and disrupting the offensive flow when he over-dribbles and fires up forced shots. For quite awhile, he had few assists but he has shown growth in that area recently. He still has work to do.
Jaylen Brown: B+
Offensively, he has clearly worked on his game in the off-season. Whereas last year, he was often a poor finisher at the rim unless he could dunk, he now is much improved. And he has developed a mid-range game. He can be an outstanding defender but he still has lapses and gets into unnecesary foul trouble.
Kemba Walker: B+
He is a scorer who also plays solid defense. Offensively, he is not reluctant to take big shots and defensively he has been consistent. He has, since Hayward’s departure, had a tendency to over-dribble and has been turnover-prone as a result which may be partly due to pressure he perceives to be on him to score. His personality is a monumental contrast to his predecessor at point guard.
Daniel Theis: B
He is a solid player on both ends of the floor. He is not featured in the offense so he is not asked to score. His only weakness is that he is often physically overmatched with the man he is assigned to guard. He knows where his shots come in the offense and he never forces the issue.
Marcus Smart: A
Marcus has been the outstanding player thus far, especially when you consider that he is, and has been, playing hurt. He sometimes has a tendency to over-shoot but also almost always immediately makes up for offensive miscues with an outstanding play on the defense.
Eric Kanter: B
His progress has been hindered by a deep knee bruise which caused him to miss 7 games early on and he has been working to get into game shape ever since. He is the quintessential offensive rebounder and scorer in the paint and, as such, fills a very important role for this team. He is also improving as a pick-setter. Look for him to show even more improvement during the next quarter.
Semi Ojeleye: c+
It is obvious that he has worked on his offensive game, which has improved, but he still needs to become more of an offensive force. He continues to be a solid defensive player. Last year, he lacked the ability to drive to the hoop but that has improved. He does need to look for his shot more often.
Brad Wanamaker: B+
He has been the surprise of the roster. One wonders why he was not discovered last year when he received very few meaningful minutes. He has brought scoring and assists to the offense and has been steady on defense and with rebounding. He will likely get even more minutes while Smart recovers from several of his recent injuries.
Carsen Edwards: C
Like most rookies, he has had difficulty getting minutes and has often forced shots in an attempt to prove his value to the team. He has worked hard on defense but is not yet a solid defender. Basically, he needs more minutes in order to build his confidence; perhaps he will get more time if Smart remains out of the lineup for very long.
Grant Williams: C
Already a solid defender who can guard multiple positions, he has impressed on defense but struggled with his shot. Part of that is due to the fact that he is a work in progress with treys and those are the only shots he has been set up for during his limited time on the floor. He needs to have a play run for him so that he can see the ball go in and his confidence will quickly improve.
Robert Williams: C
Robert has been inconsistent in his limited minutes so far. He, too, could benefit from additional minutes but that is unlikely to happen with Theis and Kanter ahead of him. He also has shown a tendency toward frequent injury which is a concern since he is definitely on the thin side.
Javonte Green: Incomplete
He has a really tough job because he is expected to perform but he has no idea when he is likely to get minutes in order to do so. He has shown potential to be effective on both ends of the floor and he is an especially good finisher at the rim. He needs consistent minutes but, barring injury, that is unlikely to happen this season.
Vincent Poirier: Incomplete
He is the fourth center and only get minutes because of injury to one or two of the three ahead of him. He has not been given enough minutes to make any kind of reasonable assessment.
Romeo Langford: Incomplete
One of the beat writers gave this kid an F which I felt was patently unfair. He was selected with the 14th pick in the draft after playing hurt his entire freshman year at Indiana with a hand injury. As a result of necessary surgery to repair his hand, he missed the entire summer league and pre-season. Since the season began, he has suffered two ankle sprains, one with the Cs and the other with the Red Claws where he was sent to get playing time. This kid is 19 years old, cut him a break; he obviously isn’t getting hurt on purpose. He is a rangy, quick wing player with exceptionally long arms who may someday be able to display his talents.
Coaching Staff: B+
The staff has built decent morale on this team after a year where that was a serious problem and that has contributed to the fine start. Some of their defensive match-ups have been problematical and, while Smart can clearly guard anyone in a pinch, the team will be better off if he spends less time guarding much bigger and heavier opponents, since backs down from no one.
This team plays best when they defend early and often. Lately, there has been a tendency to focus on offense early in games and play defense later when needed. Since it is never a good idea to allow shooters to see the ball go in the hoop early in a game, without a hard contest, this approach is counter productive for this team. Hopefully, the coaching staff will not continue to allow this to happen.